Martino: IG – Take a Closer Look at Palm Beach Gardens!
Posted by Michael Martino on October 16, 2016 · 5 Comments
On September 20th the local section of the Palm Beach Post ballyhooed the following headline…
Palm Beach Gardens
Inspector General Report
IG: GARDENS VIOLATED LAW ON CLUBHOUSE
City didn’t record some meetings concerning $4.5 million project.
Well, Mr. Inspector General you might want to take a more in depth look at the Gardens. In my opinion, this is business as usual in Palm Beach Gardens. Transparency is not a virtue or a basis upon which this City Council and its administration practices its authority. As one who regularly attends the once per month Palm Beach Gardens City Council meetings I marvel at the lack of respect and concern exhibited for open government. My sense is that our Council-Manager governance has become subservient to a form of “shadow government” that is exercising power beyond the scrutiny of the public.
Underscoring the above, one only has to study the 2013-14 “baseball stadium fiasco” where the City promoted a $100,000,000 stadium in the middle of prime single-family neighborhoods and the City Council claimed to know nothing. How about the surprise disappearance of 300 units from the Avenir development which was never adequately discussed in public and then its approval? The Shady Lakes Drive extension debacle and its contract cost confusion raise perceptions of silent maneuverings. There is the little matter of the City’s Palm Beach Gardens Municipal Golf course name change to the Sandhill Crane Golf Course without a public meeting or supposed City Council knowledge. The City’s website was renamed without benefit of a public discussion. More recently, both a park and pavilion, City property owned by the taxpayers, were named for sitting City Council members without public notice or meeting. Not for public consumption agenda reviews, development reviews, budget reviews, and who knows what other reviews, are held presumably with individual Council members, where and when is a mystery, choreographed by an unidentified whom, with what questions asked and answered, and with what records kept, is all unknown.
Is there “ill Intent” involved, I hope not. But is there “intent”, I think so. Over the last ten years or so the incumbent heavy City Council has meticulously constructed a crafty façade, a false front government, to give the appearance of transparency, but it is an opaque front. Charter changes have been deceptively presented as good for the City but have put distance between the public and its right to information and participation. Regularly scheduled workshops concerning important developments and City problems have been eliminated. Policy making seems to have matriculated into the realm of the City Administration and away from the dominion of the City Council.
From my perspective, transparency is a fundamental necessity for good government but the City Council of Palm Beach Gardens does not practice it. A City Council that meets together only once per month with its residents in a public meeting is not fostering communication. A City Council that regularly affirms important decisions with little discussion with its constituency and then casts 5 to 0 confirmatory votes is not promoting accountability. A City Council that regularly alludes that all their questions are asked and answered in some clandestine manner is not demonstrating openness. In my opinion, this protocol is not the definition of transparency but it best describes the City Council of Palm Beach Gardens attempt at it.
Actually Mayor Martino I wish there had been an Inspector General when you were on the council. I wonder just how much graft and corruption would have been found while you were the Mayor. Maybe look at some of those golf course contracts.
“Sounds like there was a nerve hit with Messer Levy. A little sensitive to the topic of transparency and accountability maybe? Not to worry. Thanks to the will and the voices of the voters the ultimate form of accountability was served to Messer Levy and his cronies in the form of term limits.”
Gina,
You must not have lived in Palm Beach Gardens for very long. I guess you don’t remember the Martino days. But you should be able to look up the fact that the voters threw Martino out. Now that I’m not in office I am free to point out hypocrisy. By the way, term limits always pass regardless of the quality of the elected body. Sadly now we are going to have no experience on our council. I doubt you’ll be happy with those results in a few years.
Yes
Actually Mr Levy, I’m born and raised in this city now work and live here. I find it funny how you have to turn back to the city yearbook with unproven allegations and you sir can’t even defend the fact that while YOU served the IG found the issues with the current council. Not one from 30 plus years ago. Nice try though.
Gina,
Really. Just because you turn a blind eye to what happened doesn’t mean it didn’t happen. The fact is there is more scrutiny today than ever before. I do see that you are also a hypocrite just like our former mayor. The IG complimented the procurement process of the City numerous times. I’m only aware of one time the IG was critical of the City. However, even in that critism the IG stated the City was within its rights.